There is no licensing requirement for personal property appraisers in the United States. Anyone can call themselves one. The Appraisers Association of America exists because that's a problem.
Real estate appraisers are state-licensed. Personal property appraisers are not. There is no government body that certifies who can appraise a $6 million guitar, a $12 million manuscript, or an archive worth eight figures. No exam. No minimum experience. No barrier to entry.
That means the person appraising a Jimi Hendrix Stratocaster for IRS Form 706 could be someone who has handled thousands of instruments at the world's leading auction houses, or someone who read a book about guitars last year. The IRS filing looks the same either way. Until it doesn't.
The Appraisers Association of America exists to draw that line.
The Appraisers Association of America was founded in 1949 and incorporated in New York State in 1950 as a non-profit trade association. It is the oldest professional association of personal property appraisers in the United States. The IRS recognises it as a qualifying appraiser organisation under its definitions for estate tax and charitable donation purposes.
Its membership sits at around 900 appraisers and affiliated professionals, spanning over 100 areas of specialisation. Many are former museum curators or heads of department at major auction houses. The AAA is not a directory you pay to join. It is an accreditation you earn and maintain.
Certified Member is the highest designation the AAA confers. The requirements are deliberately steep.
Requirement 01
A minimum of ten years of significant appraisal or related connoisseurship and marketplace experience. Not ten years in "the industry." Ten years of hands-on appraisal work.
Requirement 02
Including a 15-hour USPAP course and exam, a Theory and Methodology course and exam, and a supervised Appraisal Writing Workshop. This is not a weekend seminar.
Requirement 03
Applicants must submit three completed appraisals for review by the Admissions Committee. These must follow AAA templates and demonstrate USPAP compliance in practice, not just in theory.
Requirement 04
A formal examination in the applicant's declared area of specialisation. The entire application process takes between six months and two years.
An unqualified appraisal creates three risks, and all of them are expensive.
IRS rejection. The IRS defines "qualified appraiser" with precision. If your appraiser does not meet the criteria, your estate tax filing or charitable deduction can be disallowed entirely. The penalties are not small.
Insurance exposure. Insurers covering high-value cultural assets require formal, defensible valuations. An appraisal from an uncredentialed appraiser may not be accepted at time of claim, which is the worst possible time to discover a gap in your documentation.
Legal vulnerability. In probate, equitable distribution, or any proceeding where valuations are contested, the appraiser's credentials are examined before the appraisal itself. AAA Certified membership is the cleanest possible answer to "what qualifies this person to put a number on this object?"
AAA members are required to produce appraisals that comply with USPAP. One of the most critical USPAP requirements is independence: an appraiser cannot hold a financial interest in the property being appraised, and cannot be compensated as a percentage of the value they determine.
This is why an auction house estimate is not an appraisal. Auction houses have a consignment interest. Their "estimate" is a marketing tool designed to attract bidders. It is not an independent, defensible opinion of value, and the IRS does not accept it as one.
DIG Appraisals charges flat fees based on scope and complexity. Never a percentage of value. This is not a philosophical position. It is what USPAP requires, what the AAA mandates, and what the IRS expects.
Related Resources